| Conference/Institutions |
Number of Total Nominees |
| California Collegiate Athletic Association |
704 |
| Cal Poly Pomona |
76 |
| Cal State University East Bay |
111 |
| Cal State University Los Angeles |
51 |
| Cal State Monterey Bay |
78 |
| California State University San Marcos |
103 |
| Cal State Dominguez Hills |
81 |
| Cal State University San Bernardino |
55 |
| San Francisco State University |
85 |
| California State University Stanislaus |
64 |
| Central Atlantic Collegiate Conference |
886 |
| Caldwell University |
85 |
| Chestnut Hill College |
95 |
| Dominican University New York |
56 |
| Georgian Court University |
116 |
| Goldey-Beacom College |
75 |
| Holy Family University |
116 |
| Post University |
99 |
| Thomas Jefferson University |
122 |
| University of Bridgeport |
122 |
| Central Intercollegiate Athletic Association |
374 |
| Bluefield State University |
55 |
| Bowie State University |
26 |
| Claflin University |
64 |
| Elizabeth City State University |
51 |
| Fayetteville State University |
36 |
| Lincoln University |
43 |
| Livingstone College |
22 |
| Virginia Union University |
14 |
| Winston-Salem State University |
63 |
| Conference Carolinas |
1177 |
| Belmont Abbey College |
167 |
| Chowan University |
95 |
| Converse University |
95 |
| Emmanuel University |
201 |
| Erskine College |
87 |
| Francis Marion University |
83 |
| King University |
122 |
| North Greenville University |
84 |
| Southern Wesleyan University |
93 |
| University of North Carolina at Pembroke |
66 |
| University of Mount Olive |
84 |
| East Coast Conference |
660 |
| College of Staten Island |
35 |
| Daemen University |
69 |
| D'Youville University |
104 |
| Mercy University |
110 |
| Molloy University |
152 |
| Roberts Wesleyan University |
98 |
| St. Thomas Aquinas College |
60 |
| University of the District of Columbia |
32 |
| Great American Conference |
739 |
| Arkansas Tech University |
78 |
| East Central University |
84 |
| Harding University |
118 |
| Northwestern Oklahoma State University |
127 |
| Southeastern Oklahoma State University |
67 |
| Southern Arkansas University |
121 |
| Southwestern Oklahoma State University |
72 |
| University of Arkansas at Monticello |
72 |
| Great Lakes Intercollegiate Athletic Conference |
765 |
| Davenport University |
165 |
| Ferris State University |
112 |
| Michigan Technological University |
145 |
| Purdue University Northwest |
88 |
| University of Wisconsin-Parkside |
111 |
| Wayne State University |
144 |
| Great Lakes Valley Conference |
1360 |
| Lewis University |
62 |
| Maryville University |
190 |
| McKendree University |
219 |
| Rockhurst University |
212 |
| Truman State University |
131 |
| University of Illinois Springfield |
134 |
| University of Indianapolis |
182 |
| University of Missouri-St. Louis |
103 |
| William Jewell College |
127 |
| Great Midwest Athletic Conference |
1217 |
| Ashland University |
165 |
| Cedarville University |
98 |
| Hillsdale College |
80 |
| Ohio Dominican University |
77 |
| Tiffin University |
300 |
| Thomas More University |
48 |
| University of Findlay |
241 |
| Ursuline College |
61 |
| Walsh University |
147 |
| Great Northwest Athletic Conference |
430 |
| Central Washington University |
110 |
| Montana State University Billings |
74 |
| Saint Martin's University |
70 |
| Seattle Pacific University |
63 |
| Western Oregon University |
113 |
| Gulf South Conference |
669 |
| Auburn University at Montgomery |
69 |
| Delta State University |
120 |
| Lee University |
122 |
| University of Alabama in Huntsville |
83 |
| Union University |
66 |
| University of Montevallo |
87 |
| University of West Florida |
122 |
| Lone Star Conference |
603 |
| Angelo State University |
85 |
| St. Edward's University |
94 |
| St. Mary's University |
90 |
| Texas A&M International University |
46 |
| Texas Woman's University |
73 |
| University of Texas at Tyler |
133 |
| University of Texas of the Permian Basin |
82 |
| Mid-America Intercollegiate Athletics Association |
1316 |
| Emporia State University |
124 |
| Fort Hays State University |
104 |
| Missouri Southern State University |
86 |
| Missouri Western State University |
122 |
| Northwest Missouri State University |
157 |
| Pittsburg State University |
120 |
| Rogers State University |
89 |
| University of Central Missouri |
147 |
| University of Central Oklahoma |
82 |
| University of Nebraska Kearney |
159 |
| Washburn University |
126 |
| Mountain East Conference |
647 |
| Fairmont State University |
105 |
| Frostburg State University |
142 |
| Point Park University |
96 |
| University of Charleston |
152 |
| West Liberty University |
122 |
| West Virginia State University |
30 |
| Northeast 10 Conference |
874 |
| Adelphi University |
185 |
| Assumption University |
143 |
| Bentley University |
212 |
| Saint Anselm College |
65 |
| Saint Michael's College |
126 |
| Southern New Hampshire University |
143 |
| Northern Sun Intercollegiate Conference |
1743 |
| Augustana University |
225 |
| Bemidji State University |
134 |
| Concordia University St Paul |
166 |
| University of Minnesota Crookston |
57 |
| Minnesota State University Moorhead |
110 |
| Minnesota State University Mankato |
191 |
| Northern State University |
122 |
| St. Cloud State University |
110 |
| University of Mary |
152 |
| University of Minnesota Duluth |
129 |
| University of Sioux Falls |
211 |
| Winona State University |
136 |
| Pacific West Conference |
1272 |
| Academy of Art University |
27 |
| Azusa Pacific University |
148 |
| Biola University |
191 |
| Chaminade University |
89 |
| Concordia University Irvine |
152 |
| Dominican University of California |
117 |
| Fresno Pacific University |
114 |
| Hawaii Pacific University |
83 |
| Menlo College |
108 |
| Point Loma Nazarene University |
108 |
| University of Hawaii at Hilo |
76 |
| Westmont College |
59 |
| Peach Belt Conference |
625 |
| Augusta University |
79 |
| Clayton State University |
19 |
| Flagler College |
154 |
| Georgia College & State University |
69 |
| Lander University |
172 |
| University of North Georgia |
59 |
| University of South Carolina at Aiken |
73 |
| Pennsylvania State Athletic Conference |
2035 |
| Bloomsburg University |
160 |
| East Stroudsburg University |
242 |
| Gannon University |
164 |
| Indiana University of Pennsylvania |
130 |
| Kutztown University |
150 |
| Lock Haven University |
119 |
| Mansfield University |
43 |
| PennWest-California University |
128 |
| PennWest-Clarion University |
55 |
| University of Pittsburgh at Johnstown |
58 |
| Seton Hill University |
199 |
| Shepherd University |
90 |
| Shippensburg University |
137 |
| Slippery Rock University |
209 |
| West Chester University (Pa.) |
151 |
| Rocky Mountain Athletic Conference |
939 |
| Adams State University |
82 |
| Chadron State College |
85 |
| Colorado Christian University |
83 |
| Colorado Mesa University |
280 |
| Colorado State University Pueblo |
139 |
| Metropolitan State University of Denver |
93 |
| New Mexico Highlands University |
52 |
| Western Colorado University |
125 |
| South Atlantic Conference |
1755 |
| Anderson University |
142 |
| Carson-Newman University |
151 |
| Catawba College |
207 |
| Coker University |
136 |
| Emory & Henry University |
167 |
| Lincoln Memorial University |
192 |
| Mars Hill University |
125 |
| Newberry College |
192 |
| Tusculum University |
129 |
| University of Virginia Wise |
122 |
| Wingate University |
192 |
| Southern Intercollegiate Athletic Conference |
425 |
| Albany State University |
45 |
| Benedict College |
52 |
| Edward Waters University |
48 |
| Miles College |
120 |
| Morehouse College |
32 |
| Savannah State University |
39 |
| Spring Hill College |
89 |
| Sunshine State Conference |
1525 |
| Barry University |
124 |
| Eckerd College |
82 |
| Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University |
171 |
| Florida Southern College |
241 |
| Florida Tech |
138 |
| Lynn University |
176 |
| Nova Southeastern University |
152 |
| Palm Beach Atlantic University |
88 |
| Rollins College |
180 |
| University of Tampa |
173 |