| Institution | # Nominees | | Institution | # Nominees |
| California Collegiate | | | Mountain East | |
| Cal Poly Pomona | 33 | | Notre Dame College | 49 |
| California State University - Monterey Bay | 34 | | University of Charleston | 64 |
| Chico State University | 28 | | University of Virginia Wise | 17 |
| Humboldt State University | 40 | | Urbana University | 43 |
| Sonoma State University | 39 | | | 173 |
| 174 | | Northeast 10 | |
| CACC | | | Assumption College | 48 |
| Bloomfield College | 21 | | Bentley | 98 |
| Caldwell College | 51 | | Le Moyne College | 87 |
| Felician College | 28 | | Pace University | 36 |
| Georgian Court University | 24 | | Southern Connecticut State University | 37 |
| Goldey Beacom College | 21 | | Southern New Hampshire University | 70 |
| Holy Family University | 30 | | Stonehill College | 53 |
| Philadelphia University | 67 | | University of New Haven | 45 |
| University of the Sciences | 27 | | | 474 |
| Wilmington University | 43 | | NSIC | |
| 312 | | Augustana College | 62 |
| CIAA | | | Bemidji State University | 39 |
| Chowan University | 32 | | Concordia University St Paul | 70 |
| Shaw University | 5 | | Minnesota State University Moorhead | 67 |
| Virginia State University | 21 | | Minnesota State University, Mankato | 75 |
| 58 | | Minot State University | 41 |
| Conference Carolinas | | | Northern State University | 88 |
| Erskine College | 23 | | St. Cloud State University | 76 |
| King University | 79 | | University of Mary | 64 |
| Limestone College | 161 | | University of Minnesota - Crookston | 32 |
| University of Mount Olive | 58 | | University of Minnesota - Duluth | 53 |
| 321 | | University of Sioux Falls | 60 |
| ECC | | | Wayne State College | 58 |
| Dowling College | 42 | | Winona State University | 84 |
| LIU Post | 68 | | | 869 |
| Mercy College | 37 | | PacWest | |
| Molloy College | 44 | | Academy of Art University | 10 |
| Queen's College | 28 | | BYU - Hawaii | 35 |
| St. Thomas Aquinas College | 31 | | California Baptist University | 38 |
| University of the District of Columbia | 17 | | Chaminade University | 20 |
| 267 | | Dixe State University | 64 |
| Great American Conference | | | Dominican University of California | 49 |
| East Central University | 57 | | Fresno Pacific University | 39 |
| Northwestern Oklahoma State University | 22 | | Hawaii Pacific University | 40 |
| University of Arkansas Monticello | 27 | | Holy Names University | 22 |
| 106 | | Notre Dame de Namur University | 17 |
| GLIAC | | | Point Loma Nazarene University | 40 |
| Ashland University | 73 | | | 374 |
| Grand Valley State University | 103 | | Peach Belt | |
| Lake Erie College | 61 | | Armstrong State University | 24 |
| Michigan Tech University | 76 | | Clayton State University | 17 |
| Saginaw Valley State University | 68 | | Flagler College | 28 |
| 381 | | Francis Marion University | 38 |
| GLVC | | | Georgia College | 45 |
| Bellarmine University | 62 | | Georgia Regents University | 20 |
| Maryville University | 73 | | University of Montevallo | 55 |
| Missouri S&T | 49 | | University of North Carolina Pembroke | 36 |
| University of Indianapolis | 86 | | University of North Georgia | 22 |
| University of Southern Indiana | 54 | | University of South Carolina Aiken | 29 |
| 324 | | | 314 |
| GNAC | | | PSAC | |
| Central Washington University | 43 | | Bloomsburg | 56 |
| Seattle Pacific University | 50 | | California University of PA | 70 |
| Western Oregon University | 32 | | Clarion University of PA | 100 |
| Western Washington University | 33 | | East Stroudsburg University | 65 |
| 158 | | Edinboro University | 48 |
| Gulf South | | | Gannon University | 89 |
| Christian Brothers University | 26 | | Kutztown University | 64 |
| Union University | 31 | | Lock Haven University | 50 |
| University of North Alabama | 30 | | Seton Hill University | 129 |
| University of West Florida | 32 | | Shippensburg University | 70 |
| 119 | | Slippery Rock University | 78 |
| Heartland | | | University of Pittsburgh at Johnstown | 24 |
| Dallas Baptist University | 36 | | West Chester University | 93 |
| Lubbock Christian University | 43 | | | 936 |
| Oklahoma Christian University | 44 | | RMAC | |
| Rogers State University | 27 | | Black Hills State University | 32 |
| St. Edward's University | 50 | | Fort Lewis College | 42 |
| St. Mary's University | 48 | | Western New Mexico University | 31 |
| Texas A&M International University | 30 | | Western State Colorado University | 43 |
| University of Arkansas Fort Smith | 17 | | | 148 |
| 295 | | SIAC | |
| Independent | | | Albany State University | 3 |
| Palm Beach Atlantic University | 34 | | Spring Hill College | 44 |
| 34 | | | 47 |
| Lone Star | | | South Atlantic | |
| Cameron University | 11 | | Coker College | 57 |
| Texas A&M University Kingsville | 20 | | Newberry College | 72 |
| Texas Woman's University | 31 | | Queens University of Charlotte | 97 |
| 62 | | Wingate University | 67 |
| MIAA | | | | 293 |
| Emporia State University | 65 | | Sunshine | |
| Fort Hays State University | 60 | | Barry University | 48 |
| Lindenwood University | 126 | | Eckerd College | 30 |
| Missouri Southern State University | 49 | | Florida Institute of Technology | 83 |
| Northeastern State University | 27 | | Florida Southern College | 87 |
| Northwest Missouri State University | 93 | | Lynn University | 62 |
| Pittsburg State University | 67 | | Nova Southeastern University | 57 |
| University of Central Missouri | 63 | | Rollins College | 78 |
| University of Central Oklahoma | 53 | | Saint Leo University | 83 |
| University of Nebraska at Kearney | 66 | | University of Tampa | 50 |
| 669 | | | 578 |
| | | | |